Comparing Great Athletes

Who was better? A blog that examines the greats of sports history against each other.

Sunday, January 12, 2020

Updated Top 20 Quarterbacks Ever


Player
Team
Yrs
TDs
Ints
Yds
Titles
MVP
ProB
CompPct
WinPct
Playoff
*1. Tom Brady
Patriots
18
563
179
74,571
6
3
14
.640
.774
30-11
2. Joe Montana
49ers
15
293
139
40,551
4
2
8
.632
.713
16-7
3. Peyton Manning
Colts
17
557
251
71,940
2
5
14
.653
.702
14-13
4. John Elway
Broncos
16
334
226
51,475
2
1
9
.569
.641
14-7
*5. Drew Brees
Saints
18
570
237
77,416
1
0
12
.676
.595
8-8
6. Brett Favre
Packers
19
522
336
71,838
1
3
11
.620
.624
13-11
7. Dan Marino
Dolphins
16
429
252
61,361
0
1
8
.594
.613
8-10
*8. Aaron Rodgers
Packers
12
392
84
46,949
1
2
7
.646
.649
9-7
9. Johnny Unitas
Colts
17
303
253
40,239
3
3
10
.546
.634
6-2
10. Steve Young
49ers
15
275
107
33,124
3
1
7
.643
.657
8-6
*11. Ben Rothlsbgr
Steelers
15
382
191
56,545
2
0
6
.643
.667
13-8
12. Fran Tarkenton
Vikings
18
374
266
47,003
0
0
9
.570
.519
6-5
*13. Eli Manning
Giants
16
373
244
57,023
2
0
4
.603
.500
8-4
*14. Philip Rivers
Chargers
14
400
198
59,271
0
0
8
.647
.549
5-6
15. Warren Moon
Oilers
17
313
233
49,325
0
0
9
.584
.502
3-7
16. Kurt Warner
Rams
10
211
128
32,344
1
2
4
.655
.578
9-4
*17. Matt Ryan
Falcons
12
330
147
51,186
0
1
4
.654
.577
4-6
18. Donvn McNabb
Eagles
13
263
117
37,276
0
0
6
.590
.613
9-7
19. Tony Romo
Cowboys
10
253
117
34,183
0
0
4
.653
.614
2-4
20. Terry Bradshaw
Steelers
13
244
210
27,989
4
1
3
.519
.677
14-5

Saturday, December 1, 2018

A Great Fight; A Great Divisional Future

In the wake of Deontay Wilder and Tyson Fury's exciting draw in last night's battle at the Staples Center, the focus shifts from analysis of the action to possibilities for the future.  There is no doubt that both Deontay Wilder (40-0-1, 39 KOs) and Tyson Fury (27-0-1, 19 KOs) deserve recognition as champions.  Ironically, Wilder was able to defend his WBC Title with the draw and Fury was able to retain his identity as the lineal champ.  The man who beat the man who beat the man...After 28 fights, no one has yet defeated Tyson Fury.

The first thing to show itself in the contest was Fury's effective strategies.  Fury was much more offensively successful than he was in his other 'super fight' against Wladimir Klitschko.  Fury was able to catch Wilder quite often with stiff jabs and crisp right hands.  By round 6, Wilder's face was showing the impact of Fury's offensive accuracy.  Wilder was still throwing hard, threatening power shots but both his inactivity and inaccuracy had him looking like the strategic loser of the bout.

In round 9, Wilder's brute force finally paid dividends, as he drove Fury to the canvas with a combination of cuffing shots.  Fury rose and recovered, but Wilder turned it into a competitive fight with that knockdown.

Fury returned to effective boxing in round 10, putting Wilder in a desperate position entering round 11.  But Wilder rose to the occasion and was the more aggressive fighter down the stretch, chasing Fury and occasionally landing with wide, powerful shots.  Finally, in round 12, Wilder landed 2 crushing shots on Fury that most likely had ended the contest.  Fury lay flat on his back.  Here he was, the wild yet powerful champion Wilder, scoring yet another late knockdown with the sheer force of his will.  Yet at the count of 9, Fury rose.  He beat the count and then began scoring with hard shots to end the round.  Wilder almost caught him, but Fury took it to the judges.  It seemed likely to be close.

In the end, 115-111 Wilder, 114-110 Fury and 113-113 are not the worst scorecards I've ever seen.  It's not even close to the worst draw I've ever seen, and in many ways it works out quite well for both fighters.  I thought Fury won by a point.  But one point should never be enough to ensure a clear decision, and Wilder's 2 knockdowns gave great credibility to an even result.  Deontay Wilder saved his title with a 12th round knockdown.  Tyson Fury showed the world that he is perhaps better than ever.  Things could be worse for the Heavyweights.

The future of the division could hardly be brighter.  Before this fight, many considered Wilder and Joshua to be nearly even with each other.  Now we know that Wilder and Fury are quite even, leaving a very real possibility that the best man in the division is still decidedly unclear, but ultimately remains to be proven between Anthony Joshua, Tyson Fury and Deontay Wilder.

Here's to a Fury win in a rematch with Wilder, and the mega fight with Anthony Joshua we'd all love to see...


Monday, October 30, 2017

100 Greatest Sportsmen of All Time (Across All Major Sports)

  ATHLETE Sport               Greatness Era
1. Michael Jordan  BASKETBALL     1984-1998
2. Wayne Gretzky HOCKEY             1979-1994
3. Tom Brady FOOTBALL          2002-present
4. Michael Phelps  OLYMPICS          2003-2016
5. Roger Federer TENNIS               2003-present
6. Sugar Ray Robinson  BOXING              1943-1957
7. Babe Ruth   BASEBALL          1916-1934
8. Muhammad Ali BOXING              1963-1975
9. Pele  SOCCER             1958-1970
10. Usain Bolt  OLYMPICS           2007-2016
11. Bill Russell  BASKETBALL      1956-1967
12. Jim Brown FOOTBALL           1957-1965
13. Jerry Rice FOOTBALL           1986-1998
14. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar  BASKETBALL   1969-1986
15. Carl Lewis  OLYMPICS           1983-1996
16. Joe Montana  FOOTBALL           1981-1993
17. Cy Young   BASEBALL           1892-1908
18. Hank Aaron  BASEBALL           1955-1973
19. Floyd Mayweather Jr.   BOXING              2001-2015
20. Ted Williams  BASEBALL           1939-1958
21. Lionel Messi  SOCCER              2007-present
22. Joe Louis  BOXING               1935-1948
23. Magic Johnson          BASKETBALL      1979-1991
24. LeBron James  BASKETBALL      2004-present
25. Bobby Orr  HOCKEY              1967-1975
26. Ty Cobb   BASEBALL           1907-1927
27. Wilt Chamberlain  BASKETBALL      1959-1972
28. Mark Spitz   OLYMPICS           1967-1972
29. Cristiano Ronaldo  SOCCER              2006-present
30. Rafael Nadal  TENNIS                2005-present
31. Pete Sampras  TENNIS                1990-2000
32. Walter Payton  FOOTBALL           1976-1986
33. Larry Bird   BASKETBALL      1979-1988
34. Willie Mays  BASEBALL           1954-1970
35. Barry Bonds  BASEBALL           1990-2004
36. Henry Armstrong BOXING               1937-1943
37. Mario Lemieux  HOCKEY              1984-1997
38. Walter Johnson  BASEBALL           1910-1925
39. Lawrence Taylor   FOOTBALL           1981-1990
40. Diego Maradona   SOCCER              1979-1990
41. Gordie Howe  HOCKEY               1949-1970
42. Harry Greb  BOXING                1918-1926
43. Jack Nicklaus  GOLF                     1962-1980
44. Lou Gehrig   BASEBALL            1926-1937
45. Tim Duncan  BASKETBALL        1998-2010
46. Peyton Manning  FOOTBALL            1999-2014
47. Marvin Hagler  BOXING                 1978-1987
48. Tiger Woods  GOLF                     1997-2013
49. Shaquille O’Neal  BASKETBALL        1992-2005
50. Roger Clemens BASEBALL             1986-2005
51. Julio Cesar Chavez      BOXING                 1985-1995
52. Bobby Hull     HOCKEY                1959-1978
53. Josef Bican  SOCCER                1930-1952
54. Arnold Palmer GOLF                      1958-1967
55. Kobe Bryant BASKETBALL         1998-2013
56. Willie Pep BOXING                  1942-1951
57. Gene Tunney BOXING                  1922-1928
58. Emmitt Smith FOOTBALL              1991-2000
59. Alexander Karelin OLYMPICS              1988-2000
60. Novak Djokovic TENNIS                   2008-2016
61. Hakeem Olajuwon BASKETBALL          1984-1997
62. Stan Musial BASEBALL               1943-1957
63. Oscar Robertson BASKETBALL          1960-1971
64. Sugar Ray Leonard BOXING                   1979-1988
65. Johnny Unitas FOOTBALL              1957-1967
66. Jaromir Jagr HOCKEY                  1992-2006 
67. Rod Laver TENNIS                    1964-1970
68. John Elway FOOTBALL              1985-1997
69. Edwin Moses OLYMPICS               1976-1987
70. Alex Rodriguez BASEBALL               1996-2010
71. Thomas Hearns BOXING                   1980-1991
72. Jerry West BASKETBALL          1961-1973
73. Maurice Richard HOCKEY                  1943-1957
74. Roberto Duran BOXING                   1972-1983
75. Barry Sanders FOOTBALL               1989-1997
76. Derek Jeter BASEBALL               1996-2012
77. Bjorn Borg TENNIS                    1974-1981
78. Julius Erving BASKETBALL          1971-1984
79. Romario SOCCER                  1988-2002
80. Ben Hogan GOLF                        1946-1953
81. Ray Lewis FOOTBALL               1997-2010
82. Brett Favre FOOTBALL               1994-2009
83. Ken Rosewall             TENNIS                     1953-1972
84. Carlos Monzon BOXING                    1970-1977
85. Sergei Bubka OLYMPICS               1983-1997
86. Karl Malone BASKETBALL          1986-2001
87. Manny Pacquiao BOXING                   2003-2014
88. Christy Mathewson BASEBALL               1903-1914
89. Jimmy Connors TENNIS                    1973-1984
90. Jim Thorpe OLYMPICS               1912-1923
91. Jesse Owens OLYMPICS               1933-1936
92. Moses Malone BASKETBALL           1977-1987
93. Mariano Rivera BASEBALL               1996-2013
94. Elgin Baylor BASKETBALL          1958-1970
95. Bobby Jones GOLF                       1923-1930
96. Steve Yzerman HOCKEY                  1987-2000
97. Randy Moss FOOTBALL              1998-2009
98. Michael Johnson OLYMPICS               1991-2000
99. Bill Tilden TENNIS                    1920-1935
100. Rocky Marciano BOXING                   1951-1955